Publication Misconduct and Investigation of Allegations

The Journal of Sinology (JSINO) investigates credible allegations of publication misconduct involving submitted manuscripts and published articles. The journal assesses each case on the evidence, gives the parties concerned an opportunity to respond, and limits disclosure to those who need the information to assess or resolve the case.

Conduct Subject to Review

  • Plagiarism. The journal screens all submissions using similarity detection software. A similarity index above 30%, after excluding quotations and references, may result in rejection following editorial assessment of the overlapping material. The similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism.
  • Fabrication and falsification. Authors must report their data, methods, and findings accurately. Inventing data or materially misrepresenting evidence or results constitutes misconduct.
  • Simultaneous submission. Authors must not submit the same manuscript to another journal or conference while it is under consideration by JSINO.
  • Authorship concerns. The author list must reflect actual contributions. Authors must resolve disagreements about inclusion and order before submission. Allegations of omitted, undeserved, or unauthorized authorship are assessed on the evidence.
  • Peer review manipulation. Fabricated reviewer identities, fraudulent review reports, and other attempts to improperly influence peer review constitute misconduct. Confirmed manipulation is grounds for rejection of a submitted manuscript.

Investigation Process and Timeline

The journal aims to complete its investigation and communicate a decision within 30 calendar days of receiving the allegation. The timeline below applies to both submitted manuscripts and published articles.

Timeline Stage Journal action
Days 1–5 Initial assessment Acknowledge receipt, assess whether the allegation is specific and supported by sufficient information to investigate, and check for conflicts of interest. Appoint an independent committee when warranted.
Days 6–10 Evidence review and notification Review the relevant records and use similarity detection or other checks as appropriate. If the case proceeds, notify the parties concerned of the allegation and invite a written response.
Days 11–20 Response period Allow the parties concerned to respond and provide supporting documents. Request clarification where needed and assess the responses alongside the available evidence.
Days 21–30 Decision and communication The Editorial Board, excluding members with conflicts of interest, reviews the findings and determines the outcome. The journal communicates the decision and its reasons to the parties concerned, subject to confidentiality.

If evidence from an institution or another external party is needed, or if fairness requires more time for a response, the journal will provide a written update by Day 30 explaining the delay and giving a revised decision date.

The journal may close an unsubstantiated allegation without further action. When action is warranted, the outcome will reflect the seriousness of the findings and the status of the manuscript or article. Measures may include rejection of a submission, correction or retraction of a published article, notification of relevant institutions or funders, or suspension of future submissions.